Checklist
10 questions to ask a potential screening provider
The best vendor conversations are specific. These questions help you move past sales language and compare how each provider actually works.
1. Which searches are included, and which are add-ons?
Ask for a plain-language breakdown of every search in the package, including criminal searches, identity checks, verifications, motor vehicle records, drug testing, international searches, and occupational health services. Then ask which fees are variable or passed through from courts, schools, employers, labs, or international sources.
2. Where does the information come from?
Source quality matters. Ask whether criminal records come from county courts, state repositories, federal courts, databases, or a combination. If database searches are used, ask how possible matches are confirmed before reporting.
3. How do you support FCRA workflows?
The FTC explains that employers using a background screening company may have FCRA obligations, including disclosure, authorization, and adverse-action steps. Ask whether the provider supports compliant disclosure and authorization flows, pre-adverse notices, final adverse action notices, report copies, summary-of-rights delivery, and audit history.
4. How do you help employers evaluate criminal record information fairly?
The EEOC provides guidance and resources for employers considering arrest and conviction records. Ask how the provider helps your team avoid blanket decision-making, distinguish arrest and conviction information, and document individualized review processes when appropriate.
5. What happens when a candidate disputes a report?
Disputes are a test of provider quality. Ask who handles the dispute, how the candidate is updated, how reinvestigations are documented, how corrections are communicated, and what your team sees in the system.
6. What are your typical turnaround times, and what causes delays?
Look for transparent ranges by search type rather than one average. County court delays, employer verification responsiveness, school records, drug testing logistics, and international sources can all affect timing.
7. What does the candidate experience look like?
Ask to see the candidate portal. Check whether it is mobile-friendly, accessible, clear about required information, and easy for candidates to use when they need help. Candidate confusion creates recruiter work.
8. Which systems do you integrate with?
Ask whether the provider integrates with your ATS, HRIS, onboarding system, single sign-on, or reporting tools. Confirm whether the integration supports ordering, status updates, final reports, package mapping, permissions, and adverse-action workflows.
9. How do you protect data?
Background screening involves sensitive personal information. Ask about access controls, encryption, retention, deletion, audit logs, vendor management, incident response, and who can view reports inside your organization.
10. What will implementation require from us?
Ask for a real implementation plan. You want to know who owns package setup, policy configuration, adverse action templates, billing setup, integrations, user training, and launch support. If the provider cannot explain implementation clearly, the work may land on your team later.
How to use this checklist
Bring the same questions to each finalist and compare the specificity of the answers. This checklist is general information, not legal advice.